Using Pinguicula to Control Fungus Gnats

Fungus gnats are the small dark flies that lift off the soil when you water a houseplant. The adults are harmless and live about a week. The larvae live in the top inch or two of damp potting mix, feeding on fungus and rotting organic matter, and one pot can turn out a new generation every three to four weeks. Yellow sticky cards catch some of the adults. A Mexican butterwort (Pinguicula) catches them all day, on every leaf, because that is how the plant eats.

How a butterwort catches them

The upper surface of a Pinguicula leaf carries thousands of tiny stalked glands, each topped with a droplet of sticky mucilage. A gnat lands on what looks like a wet surface and cannot leave. Other glands on the leaf release digestive enzymes, and the leaf absorbs what they break down. On the limestone slopes of central Mexico where most of these species grow, that is the plant's main source of nitrogen. On a windowsill it works the same way, and after a few weeks the leaves carry a visible scatter of dark specks.

The difference from a sticky card is that the leaf is alive. The plant keeps making fresh mucilage and fresh leaves, so it never fills up, and it keeps going through the weeks when you have stopped replacing the cards.

Where the gnats come from

Gnats mean wet soil. The larvae need the top layer of the mix to stay damp for the two weeks or so it takes them to develop. Overwatering, a pot too big for its plant, or a dim spot where the soil dries slowly will all keep them going. Bagged potting mix can carry eggs before you ever open it.

That sets expectations. If the soil stays wet, the population keeps coming back from below no matter how many adults get caught. A butterwort works best alongside a change in watering, and it cannot do the job on its own if the pots stay soggy.

Where to put the plant

Adult gnats do not travel far from the pot they hatched in. Put the butterwort on the same shelf as the infested plants, at the same height, and ideally in among them. A butterwort on a high shelf above the problem catches a fraction of what the same plant catches sitting between the pots.

It still needs its own conditions: bright indirect light and distilled or rainwater only. A grow-light shelf with the rest of your collection is fine. A windowsill crowded with houseplants is close to ideal.

Which plants catch the most

Any Mexican Pinguicula in active growth catches gnats. Leaf area is what separates them. Of the plants we grow, Pinguicula 'Aphrodite' has by far the most surface, with long arching leaves that can reach 10 inches across in strong light. P. gigantea × moctezumae is the other big one at about 8 inches, and it keeps its leaves through winter instead of pulling back into a small rosette.

For a first plant, Pinguicula 'Johanna' and 'Pirouette' are smaller, cheaper and easier. Each catches fewer gnats than a large plant, but two of them spread across a shelf usually do better than one big plant sitting in a corner.

Sundews do the same job with dew-tipped tentacles. The red Cape sundew is just as effective and wants to stand in a tray of water, which suits people who already water that way. All of these are grouped in plants for fungus gnats.

What to expect

A butterwort brings the numbers down and keeps them down. It removes adults before they lay the next round of eggs, so each generation is smaller than the last, but it cannot reach larvae already in the soil. Count on a clear drop over two to four weeks. You will see gnats stuck to the leaves within hours, which is satisfying but is not the same as the problem being solved.

With a heavy infestation, pair the plant with the usual fixes: let the top inch of mix dry out between waterings, and put out yellow sticky cards for the first couple of weeks to knock the adult numbers down. One butterwort per shelf of plants is a reasonable ratio. Once the population is low, the plant alone usually holds it there.

Keeping the leaves sticky

A butterwort only catches gnats while its leaves are producing mucilage, and that depends on light, water and the time of year.

Light drives dew. A plant in a dim corner turns matte and green and catches very little. Water quality decides whether the plant lives at all: minerals in tap water build up in the mix and damage the roots, and a butterwort dying of tap water fades slowly enough that people rarely connect the two. Use distilled, reverse-osmosis or rainwater only. And in winter, most Mexican species swap their sticky leaves for a tight rosette of small succulent leaves that catch nothing. That is normal, and the sticky leaves come back in spring. The full routine for light, water, soil and the winter rest is in the Mexican Pinguicula care guide.

Common questions

Will one plant clear a whole room?

No. One plant covers the pots immediately around it. If you have plants on three surfaces in a room, you want a butterwort on each.

Do I need to feed it anything else?

No. If it is catching gnats, it is fed. Never put fertilizer in the soil; the roots are adapted to poor ground and it burns them.

Is it safe around pets and children?

Yes. Neither butterworts nor sundews are toxic, and the leaves are only sticky enough to hold small insects.

What if the gnats come back?

Check the watering first. A population that returns almost always means the top of the mix is staying damp long enough for larvae to finish developing.

How long until I see a difference?

Two to four weeks for a real drop, assuming you also let the topsoil dry between waterings. Gnats will be stuck to the leaves within hours of putting the plant among your pots, but the adults you can see are a small part of the population.

Where to go next

If you have not grown one before, our guide to choosing your first Mexican butterwort compares the easy ones. Once a plant is settled, you can turn one rosette into several with leaf pullings.

Shop plants for fungus gnats