Species Guide

Mexican Pinguicula Species Guide

Twelve Mexican butterwort species and six popular hybrids compared: where each grows wild, how big it gets, what it does in winter and how easy it is to grow.

12 species and 6 hybrids compared Updated October 2026
In short

What are Mexican Pinguicula?

Mexican Pinguicula, or Mexican butterworts, are carnivorous plants in the genus Pinguicula that grow wild in Mexico and, for a few species, Central America. Most live on limestone or gypsum rock in places with a wet summer and a dry winter. Their sticky leaves trap small insects such as fungus gnats.

Many species are heterophyllous: they grow a sticky, carnivorous rosette in summer and a compact, non-sticky succulent rosette for the dry season. Others keep the same leaves all year. The International Carnivorous Plant Society calls them among the easiest carnivorous plants to grow.

Mexican butterworts compared

Tap a name to jump to its profile. Plants we grow link to their listing in each profile.

Mexican Pinguicula species compared. Range, habitat and size come from the botanical descriptions listed under Sources; difficulty is our own rating from growing them.
Species Native to Habitat Rosette Winter form Flowers Difficulty
Pinguicula agnataIn stock with us Hidalgo, Querétaro and Guanajuato Limestone cliffs in dry scrub and deciduous forest, 350–2,000 m Summer leaves 2.5–8 cm (1–3 in) long Mild: slightly smaller, hairy, non-sticky leaves White to violet, often white with violet tips Easy
Pinguicula cyclosecta Nuevo León; also recorded in Coahuila, San Luis Potosí and Tamaulipas Vertical limestone cliffs in pine-oak forest, about 1,000–2,200 m Small: summer leaves 1.5–6 cm long (sources vary) Distinct: loose rosette of 40–80 small leaves, October to April Intense violet with a round white throat spot Moderate
Pinguicula debbertianaIn stock with us San Luis Potosí (near El Huizache) Gypsum or limestone in semi-arid country, about 1,400–1,500 m Tiny: up to about 3.5 cm (1.4 in) across Distinct: tight rosette of up to 100 leaves, only slightly smaller Dark lilac to blue-violet with purple veins Easy
Pinguicula ehlersiae San Luis Potosí and Hidalgo; also reported from Nuevo León and Tamaulipas Gypsum or limestone, about 1,200–2,000 m (sources vary) Small: a few cm across Distinct: 40–60 tiny succulent leaves Violet to pink, with pure white forms; blooms January to March Easy
Pinguicula elizabethiae Querétaro and Hidalgo (Moctezuma and Tolimán river canyons) Steep north-facing slopes on calcareous rock, 1,000–1,600 m 5–12 cm (2–5 in) across Very distinct: a bulb-like rosette 1–2 cm across, leaves fringed with long hairs Red-purple to magenta-pink, late summer Moderate
Pinguicula emarginata Veracruz and Puebla Rock faces beside rivers in cloud forest, about 1,400–1,550 m Up to about 10 cm (4 in) across None under normal conditions (homophyllous) White to violet with purple veins; notched petal tips Easy
Pinguicula esseriana Northeastern Mexico; the exact state is disputed (San Luis Potosí or Tamaulipas) Limestone rock and moss in semi-arid scrub and oak-pine forest Small: summer leaves 1–2.5 cm long Distinct: 30–40 succulent leaves, November to April White, pink, violet or magenta; blooms mid-January to March Moderate
Pinguicula gigantea Oaxaca (near San Bartolomé Ayautla) Limestone cliffs, often in strong sun, about 500–800 m Very large: 30 cm (12 in) or more across in the wild None: the leaves just get smaller Pale violet to whitish-lilac with a violet edge Easy
Pinguicula gypsicola San Luis Potosí Crevices in gypsum hills, mostly on shaded north slopes, about 1,300 m Narrow summer leaves up to about 8 cm (3 in) long Distinct: compact rosette of 60–80 leaves Violet to purple with darker veins and a white spot Moderate
Pinguicula laueana Oaxaca (Sierra Mixe) Moss on limestone cliffs in cloud forest, above 2,000 m Summer leaves about 5 × 2.5 cm Distinct: 30–80 hairy leaves Scarlet to crimson red; orange-tinged and violet forms also occur Advanced
Pinguicula moctezumae Querétaro and Hidalgo (Moctezuma river canyon only) Wet, seeping limestone walls and stream beds, 900–1,100 m Upright, narrow leaves 6–10 cm (2–4 in) long, sometimes 13 cm Weak: forms only when the plant dries out Rose to violet-purple with a white throat; recorded in every month Moderate
Pinguicula moranensis Widespread: much of Mexico, south to Guatemala, El Salvador and Honduras Shaded rock and thin soil in oak, pine-oak and fir forest, about 800–3,200 m 6–20 cm (2.5–8 in) across Strong: a dense, houseleek-like rosette Very variable: pink, purple, magenta, lilac or white Easy

Popular hybrids

Mexican Pinguicula hybrids and cultivars compared, with their parent species.
Hybrid Parents Origin Rosette Winter form Flowers Difficulty
Pinguicula 'Johanna'In stock with us P. agnata × P. debbertiana Christian Weinberger, Germany; registered 2010 Compact rosette Winter rosette, like both parents Purple with dark veins and a pale yellow-white throat Easy
Pinguicula 'Weser'We grow this · sold out P. moranensis × P. ehlersiae H. Weiner, Hameln, Germany, 1981; registered 1998 Medium rosette Succulent winter rosette Pink-violet, often several at once Easy
Pinguicula 'Aphrodite'In stock with us P. agnata × P. moctezumae J. Flísek and K. Pásek; crossed 1998, registered 2001 Large, with long arching leaves Mild; both parents make only weak winter rosettes Violet, for much of the year Easy
Pinguicula 'Pirouette'In stock with us P. agnata × (P. moranensis × P. ehlersiae) Leo Song, California State University, Fullerton; crossed 1986, registered 2000 Medium, symmetrical pinwheel rosette May form a winter rosette if kept cool Pink-lavender Easy
Pinguicula agnata × emarginata 'Sakurahime'In stock with us P. agnata × P. emarginata Japanese clone, breeder unknown; not a registered cultivar Medium, fairly flat rosette Mild White to pale, with fine purple veins Easy
Pinguicula gigantea × moctezumaeIn stock with us P. gigantea × P. moctezumae Garden hybrid; no registered cultivar name Large, with long chartreuse leaves None: stays leafy all year Soft pink to lilac Easy

Species profiles

Twelve of the most widely grown Mexican species, in alphabetical order. Each links to its record at Kew's Plants of the World Online.

Pinguicula agnata

Described by Casper, 1963

Native to
Hidalgo, Querétaro and Guanajuato
Habitat
Limestone cliffs in dry scrub and deciduous forest, 350–2,000 m
Rosette
Summer leaves 2.5–8 cm (1–3 in) long
Winter
Mild: slightly smaller, hairy, non-sticky leaves
Flowers
White to violet, often white with violet tips
Difficulty
Easy

One of the easiest Mexican butterworts and a common first plant. Casper first described it as having no winter form, but in cultivation it makes a mild winter rosette of hairy, non-sticky leaves that root readily as leaf pullings.

Flower colour varies by clone. The 'El Lobo' form from Querétaro has pure white flowers, and some clones are scented. A 2025 study by Fleck and colleagues found weak CAM photosynthesis in P. agnata, part of the first report of CAM in any carnivorous plant. It is a parent of 'Johanna', 'Aphrodite' and 'Pirouette'.

Pinguicula cyclosecta

Described by Casper, 1963

Native to
Nuevo León; also recorded in Coahuila, San Luis Potosí and Tamaulipas
Habitat
Vertical limestone cliffs in pine-oak forest, about 1,000–2,200 m
Rosette
Small: summer leaves 1.5–6 cm long (sources vary)
Winter
Distinct: loose rosette of 40–80 small leaves, October to April
Flowers
Intense violet with a round white throat spot
Difficulty
Moderate

Recognized by the violet tint on its outer summer leaves and by deep violet flowers with nearly circular lobes, which is where the name comes from. It grows on sheer limestone in the wild but does not need an alkaline mix in cultivation.

Winter, once the succulent rosette has formed, is the best time to repot and to take leaf pullings.

Pinguicula debbertiana

Described by Speta & F. Fuchs, 1992

Native to
San Luis Potosí (near El Huizache)
Habitat
Gypsum or limestone in semi-arid country, about 1,400–1,500 m
Rosette
Tiny: up to about 3.5 cm (1.4 in) across
Winter
Distinct: tight rosette of up to 100 leaves, only slightly smaller
Flowers
Dark lilac to blue-violet with purple veins
Difficulty
Easy

One of the smallest Mexican species, so it fits a windowsill, a terrarium or a crowded grow shelf. It is strongly heterophyllous and propagates easily from detached winter leaves.

Seed is rarely produced, possibly because two different clones are needed for pollination. It is a parent of the popular hybrid 'Johanna'.

Pinguicula ehlersiae

Described by Speta & F. Fuchs, 1982

Native to
San Luis Potosí and Hidalgo; also reported from Nuevo León and Tamaulipas
Habitat
Gypsum or limestone, about 1,200–2,000 m (sources vary)
Rosette
Small: a few cm across
Winter
Distinct: 40–60 tiny succulent leaves
Flowers
Violet to pink, with pure white forms; blooms January to March
Difficulty
Easy

A small species and one of the most widely grown, because its winter leaves root very easily. Unusually, it flowers only from the winter rosette, between January and March, so a plant that looks dormant may still bloom.

Keep it on the dry side from November to April. It is a parent of 'Weser' and a grandparent of 'Pirouette'.

Pinguicula elizabethiae

Described by Zamudio, 1999

Native to
Querétaro and Hidalgo (Moctezuma and Tolimán river canyons)
Habitat
Steep north-facing slopes on calcareous rock, 1,000–1,600 m
Rosette
5–12 cm (2–5 in) across
Winter
Very distinct: a bulb-like rosette 1–2 cm across, leaves fringed with long hairs
Flowers
Red-purple to magenta-pink, late summer
Difficulty
Moderate

Named for Elizabeth Argüelles. Its winter rosette is one of the most striking in the group: a tight bulb of 60 or more small leaves, each fringed with hairs 5 to 10 mm long.

Use an airy, fast-draining mix and water only rarely from October to April.

Pinguicula emarginata

Described by Zamudio & Rzedowski, 1986

Native to
Veracruz and Puebla
Habitat
Rock faces beside rivers in cloud forest, about 1,400–1,550 m
Rosette
Up to about 10 cm (4 in) across
Winter
None under normal conditions (homophyllous)
Flowers
White to violet with purple veins; notched petal tips
Difficulty
Easy

Named for the notched (emarginate) tips of its petals, the trait that sets its flowers apart. It is homophyllous: it keeps the same sticky leaves all year and does not need a dry winter rest, so it suits a humid terrarium.

Keep the mix just barely moist and propagate from leaf cuttings. It is a parent of the agnata × emarginata clone sold as 'Sakurahime'.

Pinguicula esseriana

Described by B. Kirchner, 1981

Native to
Northeastern Mexico; the exact state is disputed (San Luis Potosí or Tamaulipas)
Habitat
Limestone rock and moss in semi-arid scrub and oak-pine forest
Rosette
Small: summer leaves 1–2.5 cm long
Winter
Distinct: 30–40 succulent leaves, November to April
Flowers
White, pink, violet or magenta; blooms mid-January to March
Difficulty
Moderate

A small species with very variable flower colour. Like P. ehlersiae, which it closely resembles, it flowers from the winter rosette in midwinter.

Its home range has been confused since it was described: plants were distributed under a San Luis Potosí locality, while later authors trace the original material to Tamaulipas. Keep it dry to barely moist from November to April.

Pinguicula gigantea

Described by Luhrs, 1995

Native to
Oaxaca (near San Bartolomé Ayautla)
Habitat
Limestone cliffs, often in strong sun, about 500–800 m
Rosette
Very large: 30 cm (12 in) or more across in the wild
Winter
None: the leaves just get smaller
Flowers
Pale violet to whitish-lilac with a violet edge
Difficulty
Easy

The largest Mexican butterwort. Both sides of its leaves carry sticky glands, which is rare in the genus, and it has no distinct winter rosette. The International Carnivorous Plant Society calls it a good windowsill plant.

Older plants are sometimes still sold under the name 'Ayautla'. It is a parent of P. gigantea × moctezumae.

Pinguicula gypsicola

Described by Brandegee, 1911

Native to
San Luis Potosí
Habitat
Crevices in gypsum hills, mostly on shaded north slopes, about 1,300 m
Rosette
Narrow summer leaves up to about 8 cm (3 in) long
Winter
Distinct: compact rosette of 60–80 leaves
Flowers
Violet to purple with darker veins and a white spot
Difficulty
Moderate

Its long, narrow summer leaves make it easy to tell apart from the broad-leaved species. Despite the name (gypsum-loving), it does not need gypsum in cultivation.

It is fussier about water than most: avoid a soggy mix even in summer, and keep it dry over winter. Well-grown plants can send up as many as 10 flower stalks in a season.

Pinguicula laueana

Described by Speta & F. Fuchs (1989; validated 2018)

Native to
Oaxaca (Sierra Mixe)
Habitat
Moss on limestone cliffs in cloud forest, above 2,000 m
Rosette
Summer leaves about 5 × 2.5 cm
Winter
Distinct: 30–80 hairy leaves
Flowers
Scarlet to crimson red; orange-tinged and violet forms also occur
Difficulty
Advanced

Known for its red flowers, which are very rare in Pinguicula; nearly all species flower in white, pink or violet. Wild flower colour ranges from scarlet and crimson to orange-tinged and violet.

Keep it dry in winter and never waterlogged. The name was first published in 1989 but only validly published in 2018, so you will see both years.

Pinguicula moctezumae

Described by Zamudio & R.Z. Ortega, 1994

Native to
Querétaro and Hidalgo (Moctezuma river canyon only)
Habitat
Wet, seeping limestone walls and stream beds, 900–1,100 m
Rosette
Upright, narrow leaves 6–10 cm (2–4 in) long, sometimes 13 cm
Winter
Weak: forms only when the plant dries out
Flowers
Rose to violet-purple with a white throat; recorded in every month
Difficulty
Moderate

Found in a single canyon, on seeping limestone so wet that its authors described it as almost subaquatic. Its long, upright leaves set it apart from every other Mexican species.

It can be kept moist all year and suits a terrarium. Seed needs hand pollination. It is a parent of 'Aphrodite' and P. gigantea × moctezumae.

Pinguicula moranensis

Described by Kunth, 1817–1818 (sources differ)

Native to
Widespread: much of Mexico, south to Guatemala, El Salvador and Honduras
Habitat
Shaded rock and thin soil in oak, pine-oak and fir forest, about 800–3,200 m
Rosette
6–20 cm (2.5–8 in) across
Winter
Strong: a dense, houseleek-like rosette
Flowers
Very variable: pink, purple, magenta, lilac or white
Difficulty
Easy

The most widespread Mexican butterwort and one of the most commonly grown, available in many forms with different flower colours. Two varieties are accepted: var. moranensis on limestone and var. neovolcanica on volcanic rock in the Trans-Mexican Volcanic Belt.

Its winter rosette is a dense mass that looks like a houseleek (Sempervivum), and it can flower from both its summer and winter rosettes. It is a parent of 'Weser' and a grandparent of 'Pirouette'.

Hybrid and cultivar profiles

Most Mexican butterworts sold today are hybrids. They are usually more vigorous than either parent and just as easy to grow. There are no verified natural hybrids among the Latin American species, so all of these were made by growers.

Pinguicula 'Johanna'

P. agnata × P. debbertiana

Origin
Christian Weinberger, Germany; registered 2010
Rosette
Compact rosette
Winter
Winter rosette, like both parents
Flowers
Purple with dark veins and a pale yellow-white throat
Difficulty
Easy

A registered cultivar that turns from soft green to cherry-pink in strong light and blooms freely. It combines the vigour of P. agnata with the colour of P. debbertiana, and it is one of our most reliable plants for beginners.

Pinguicula 'Weser'

P. moranensis × P. ehlersiae

Origin
H. Weiner, Hameln, Germany, 1981; registered 1998
Rosette
Medium rosette
Winter
Succulent winter rosette
Flowers
Pink-violet, often several at once
Difficulty
Easy

One of the oldest Mexican hybrids in cultivation and still one of the most dependable: vigorous, generous with mucilage and quick to flower. 'Sethos' is a sister cultivar with the same parents and breeder.

Pinguicula 'Aphrodite'

P. agnata × P. moctezumae

Origin
J. Flísek and K. Pásek; crossed 1998, registered 2001
Rosette
Large, with long arching leaves
Winter
Mild; both parents make only weak winter rosettes
Flowers
Violet, for much of the year
Difficulty
Easy

Gets its long, strap-like leaves from P. moctezumae and its easy nature from P. agnata. It grows into one of the largest plants on a windowsill and flowers almost constantly.

Pinguicula 'Pirouette'

P. agnata × (P. moranensis × P. ehlersiae)

Origin
Leo Song, California State University, Fullerton; crossed 1986, registered 2000
Rosette
Medium, symmetrical pinwheel rosette
Winter
May form a winter rosette if kept cool
Flowers
Pink-lavender
Difficulty
Easy

Named for its neat, pinwheel-shaped rosette. Kept warm it can grow all year without a resting phase, and it is one of the easiest butterworts to propagate from leaf pullings.

Pinguicula agnata × emarginata 'Sakurahime'

P. agnata × P. emarginata

Origin
Japanese clone, breeder unknown; not a registered cultivar
Rosette
Medium, fairly flat rosette
Winter
Mild
Flowers
White to pale, with fine purple veins
Difficulty
Easy

'Sakurahime' (Japanese for cherry blossom princess) is a trade name for one Japanese clone of this cross, not a registered cultivar name. The leaves blush strongly pink in bright light, and the veined flowers are smaller and finer than those of P. agnata.

Pinguicula gigantea × moctezumae

P. gigantea × P. moctezumae

Origin
Garden hybrid; no registered cultivar name
Rosette
Large, with long chartreuse leaves
Winter
None: stays leafy all year
Flowers
Soft pink to lilac
Difficulty
Easy

Combines the size of P. gigantea with the long leaves and steady flowering of P. moctezumae. Like both parents it has no tight winter rosette, only slower growth in the cool months. Not to be confused with 'Down Under', which is P. emarginata × moctezumae.

Which Mexican butterwort should I grow?

Best first butterwort

P. agnata, 'Weser' or 'Pirouette'

Forgiving, quick to recover from mistakes and easy to propagate. Any of the three is a good start on a bright windowsill.

Biggest plant

P. gigantea or P. gigantea × moctezumae

P. gigantea is the largest Mexican species, and its hybrid with P. moctezumae adds long leaves and steady flowers.

Small spaces and terrariums

P. debbertiana or P. emarginata

P. debbertiana stays around 3.5 cm across. P. emarginata likes steady humidity and needs no dry winter.

No winter rest to manage

P. emarginata, P. gigantea or P. gigantea × moctezumae

These keep the same leaves all year, so there is no dry season to time. Water them the same way year-round, just a little less in winter.

Unusual flowers

P. laueana or P. emarginata

P. laueana has rare red flowers; P. emarginata has notched, veined petals. P. laueana is for growers with some experience.

Common questions

What is the difference between heterophyllous and homophyllous butterworts?

Heterophyllous species, such as P. moranensis and P. gypsicola, grow two kinds of leaves: sticky, carnivorous summer leaves and a compact rosette of non-sticky, succulent leaves for the dry winter. Homophyllous species, such as P. emarginata and P. gigantea, keep more or less the same leaves all year. The difference matters most for watering: heterophyllous plants should be kept much drier in winter.

Which Mexican Pinguicula is easiest for beginners?

P. agnata and hybrids such as 'Weser', 'Pirouette' and 'Johanna' are the most forgiving. The International Carnivorous Plant Society describes Mexican butterworts as among the easiest carnivorous plants to grow.

Which Mexican butterwort grows the largest?

P. gigantea, from Oaxaca, which can reach 30 cm (12 in) or more across in the wild. 'Aphrodite' and P. gigantea × moctezumae are the largest common hybrids.

Do all Mexican Pinguicula need a dry winter?

No. Heterophyllous species form a succulent winter rosette and should be watered sparingly while they rest. Homophyllous species such as P. emarginata and P. gigantea have no true resting phase and can be watered normally, a little less in the cool months. See our care guide for how to handle the winter rosette.

Is there a Mexican butterwort with red flowers?

Yes: P. laueana from the Sierra Mixe in Oaxaca has scarlet to crimson flowers, a colour that is very rare in the genus. P. elizabethiae has red-purple to magenta flowers.

Do Mexican butterworts need gypsum or limestone in the pot?

No. Several species grow on gypsum or limestone in the wild, including P. gypsicola, P. debbertiana and P. ehlersiae, but they grow well in cultivation without it. A 1:1 mix of peat moss and perlite works for every plant in this guide.

Do Mexican butterworts catch fungus gnats?

Yes. In the growing season their leaves are covered in sticky mucilage that traps fungus gnats, fruit flies and other small insects. The winter leaves of heterophyllous species are not sticky, so they stop catching insects while they rest. See our plants for fungus gnats.

What does a registered cultivar name mean?

Cultivar names like 'Johanna', 'Weser', 'Aphrodite' and 'Pirouette' are registered with the International Carnivorous Plant Society, the official registration authority for carnivorous plant cultivars. A registered name refers to one specific plant line. Unregistered trade names, such as 'Sakurahime', are informal labels for a clone.

Sources